Vietnamese activist’s extradition battle tests Thailand’s human rights commitment

Y Quynh Bđăp’s fight against deportation from Thailand could become a first litmus test for the country’s landmark anti-torture law. 

The Cross Cultural Foundation (CrCF)
Photo of Y Quynh Bđăp. Courtesy of The Cross Cultural Foundation (CrCF)

Bangkok – In a case that could test Thailand’s commitment to protecting political refugees, Y Quynh Bđăp, a Vietnamese activist, appeared in court on 30 August for his second extradition hearing. He faces the possibility of being sent back to Vietnam, where he fears for his life.

Shackled and in prison uniform, Bđăp responded “No” when the Criminal Court judge asked him if he was willing to return to Vietnam.

The 32-year-old Vietnamese activist for religious freedom and the ethnic Montagnards has remained in Thai custody since June. If extradited, he believes he will face torture and possibly death for his activism in Vietnam.

 

Sentenced to ten years in prison

The Vietnamese government accused Bđăp of having a connection to a terrorist attack last year in the country’s Dak Lak province. While living in Thailand, Bđăp was sentenced to ten years in prison by a Vietnamese court. He has continually insisted on his innocence.

Montagnards Stand for Justice (MSFJ), an NGO Bđăp co-founded that promotes the indigenous rights of Vietnamese minorities, has been designated as a terrorist organisation by the Vietnamese government after the attack in Dak Lak province. The NGO has provided reports on religious freedom to the United Nations.

The majority of Montagnards are Evangelical Christians, who have faced severe harassment by the Vietnamese state due to practising their faith.

 

Concerns over torture and persecution

During the hearing, Bđăp expressed concern that he will die if Thailand extradites him back to Vietnam to serve his sentence. He said he has faced harsh beatings by Vietnamese authorities and been arrested multiple times since 2010. In 2018, he escaped to Thailand and received UNHCR refugee status, hoping to resettle in a third country.

The court heard opinions from a human rights expert, presented by the defence lawyer, to convince the court to drop the extradition case. Given Bđăp’s history with the Vietnamese government, the likelihood of him being tortured again is high, the lawyer argued.

 

Landmark case for Thailand’s anti-torture law

Bđăp’s extradition case will be the first time Thailand’s Anti-torture Act, specifically Article 13, will be used in a court case to halt an extradition process. Article 13 adheres to the internationally recognised principle of non-refoulement, which ensures individuals won’t be sent back to another state where they are likely to face torture or enforced disappearance.

Nadthasiri Bergman, Bđăp’s defense lawyer, urged the Court to carefully consider the Prevention and Suppression of Torture and Enforced Disappearance Act and its principles. 

“The Court must be cautious in employing it because [the law] is a milestone; it is a foundation,” Nadthasiri told HaRDstories. “The Court should listen to the experts who have done the work […], helping us achieve our goal of protecting people from torture and enforced disappearance.”

The Anti-torture Act took over ten years of advocacy by civil society groups to be enacted last year.

International attention

The international community has been vocal against Bđăp’s extradition. Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International Thailand have raised concerns and pointed to Thailand’s obligations under its law and international agreements to not proceed with the extradition process.

In July, US lawmakers urged the Prime Minister in a letter to release Bđăp from detention.

“We are concerned Y Quynh Bdap’s extradition case creates uncertainty for other Vietnamese refugees currently living in Thailand,” the letter said.

The Thai government has refused to intervene in the case, stating that any release or extradition must be decided in court.

However, according to Pornpen Khongkachankie, director of the Cross Cultural Foundation, an NGO closely monitoring the case, the government could veto the court’s decision based on Article 14 of the 2008 Extradition Act if it decides to extradite Bđăp.

“Even if the court orders the deportation, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs can overturn the extradition if the decision affects international relations,” said Pornpen.

As Thailand seeks to claim a seat on the UN Human Rights Council, the verdict on Bđăp’s would understandably be considered.  

Thailand’s track record with political refugees

Bđăp’s case highlights a growing issue for political refugees in Thailand and, more broadly, in Southeast Asia, where transnational repression has targeted regime dissidents, even those with refugee status that should have protected them.

Despite Thailand being a signatory to the Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (2007) and the International Convention for the Protection of All Persons from Enforced Disappearance (2012), political refugees in Thailand remain at risk. 

In the past, Vietnamese dissidents like Bđăp have been deported or abducted, even though Thailand has no official extradition agreement with Vietnam. 

In 2019, Dương Văn Thái, a UNHCR refugee and critic of the Vietnamese government, was abducted from Thailand and now faces a prison sentence in Vietnam for speaking against the state.

“Bđăp also mentioned the story of his arrest and being beaten, and the prison that he might be sent to in Vietnam has a history,” said Pornpen. “Since the Court has heard everything, it should be helpful to see that deportation is likely to be dangerous.”

 

The Criminal Court has scheduled to read the verdict on 30 September at 1:00 PM. 

Help support our journalism!
Your donation allows us to keep bringing you these important stories
Stay informed!

Get our latest stories direct to your inbox.