Thailand’s land bridge project clears public hearing hurdle despite protests
Forty kilometres of walking, five days of protest – but Thailand’s controversial land bridge hearing went ahead, with authorities claiming “majority support” despite the opposition from local communities.
- Published
- 3 min read
Bangkok – A diverse coalition of traditional fishermen, indigenous Moken and environmentalists gathered in the southern province of Ranong for a protest march against the Thai government’s 29 billion-dollar land bridge project.
Amid the heat, 20 of them marched from the planned port site towards central Ranong over five days. On some evenings, up to 70 people joined them. The protesters shared a common concern: the potential impact on their livelihoods and maritime ecosystem from the logistics hub that could drive industrial expansion in southern Thailand.
“The deepsea port will be built over my home and my fishing ground. It’s not only me who will be affected, but also many others,” said Thom Sinsuwan, a Muslim fisherwoman in her sixties. “If they don’t stop, I will keep protesting, even if I have to walk a thousand kilometres to the Government House.”
The controversial hearing
Tuesday’s public hearing (5 August) was a critical moment for the public to express support or raise concerns about the project. The meeting discussed the Environmental and Health Impact Assessment (EHIA) of the planned deep-sea port in Ranong’s gulf, part of the mega project designed to bypass the Malacca Strait.
Locals, businessmen and authorities gathered in a hotel in central Ranong, with several attending online. After an hour and a half, the meeting was disrupted when activists stormed the stage to voice their opposition. Outside the venue, Thom and about 100 people gathered. Nearly 400 people opposed the project that day.
Project opponents believe the assessment significantly downplays impacts on their livelihoods and environment. They also complained that the impact study failed to engage properly with the public, particularly artisanal fisherfolk who depend on the marine ecosystem.
The over 1,000-page long EHIA report was published online for public to review in mid-July, only 18 days before the public hearing. Thom, who has only a basic mobile phone, struggled to access it.
Commercial fishermen also expressed scepticism. “I have been attending the hearings since the first day, but my concerns have not really been answered,” said Apichit Vorakit, head of the shrimp farmers in Ranong during the hearing. “Natural resources are our lifelines. We don’t oppose the development but I want to know how our communities and the new development can co-exist?”
Despite calls for cancellation, the public hearing was deemed successful with “majority support for the project to progress quickly”, according to the agency responsible for the project. They did not respond to journalist questions about why their press release contradicted the local opposition witnessed during the day.
During the hearing, the project developer insisted the study met academic standards and had engaged the communities throughout the process.
A similar hearing for a deep-sea port on the Chumphon side was also declared successful the same week, despite opposing voices.
Some Ranong business owners support the infrastructure project, expecting it to bring economic growth and job opportunities.
The EHIA report will now be reviewed by the Office of Natural Resources and Environmental Policy and Planning and other authorities before construction begins next year.
Effective impact assessment?
The 68-million baht (2 million USD) EHIA study began in 2021 through collaboration between six private consulting firms, under supervision by Thailand’s Ministry of Transportation.
“The EHIA process is supposed to answer the basic questions the affected communities have in mind. If the 1,300-page report can’t do it, that is a very scary knowledge gap,” said Associate Professor Sompratana Ritphring, an hydraulic engineering expert from Kasetsart University.
She was among twelve scientists and environmental activists who analysed the state-backed EHIA report, concluding that the impact assessment fails to meet academic standards and downplays actual environmental and health impacts.
One concern is that the study does not include projections for coastal erosion or how the vast port area would address disasters from extreme weather, despite available modelling that could help project such scenarios.
To counter this, they published an alternative EHIA study which they claim is more comprehensive, whilst calling on the authorities to conduct a new impact study.
“Remember, this land bridge project is the biggest land reclamation project ever undertaken in Thailand,” Sompratana stressed. “It’s truly concerning.”
Additional reporting by Ken G Weber
Read more: What is the land bridge project?
Other news
- by Nicha Wachpanich
- by Nicha Wachpanich
